The key ideas

The Antidote: Happiness for People Who Can’t Stand Positive Thinking

Oliver Burkeman, 2012

Why does advice to look on the bright side so often make things worse? The journalist Oliver Burkeman went to a motivational show in Texas and to a night-time cemetery in a Mexican village to describe the “negative path” to happiness. The Stoics, psychologists and researchers of failure arrive at the same place: life is calmer for those who stop running from uncertainty, failure and thoughts of death.

Who it is for

For anyone irritated by calls to think positive and tired of chasing a good mood.

The effort to try to feel happy is often precisely the thing that makes us miserable.

The show that abolished the word “impossible”

A December morning, a basketball arena near San Antonio, Texas, more than fifteen thousand people in the audience. The eighty-three-year-old preacher Robert Schuller, author of dozens of books on the power of positive thinking, takes the stage. He shouts at the crowd to strike the word “impossible” from their lives. A few months later Oliver Burkeman read in the newspaper that Schuller’s cathedral, the largest glass church in America, had gone bankrupt.

Burkeman wrote a newspaper column on psychology for years and came to a conclusion that seems strange at first sight. It is precisely the effort to feel happy that often makes us unhappy. And a stubborn struggle against uncertainty, failure and sadness brings even more anxiety and sadness. The philosopher Alan Watts called this the law of reversed effort: whoever tries with all their might to stay afloat sinks.

So the author looks for a “negative path” to happiness. He finds it among the Stoics and in Buddhism, in researchers’ debates about goals and failures, at the Mexican Day of the Dead. This isn’t a call to despair. It is an antidote to a culture that sees positivity as the only road to happiness.

The closer you police your thoughts, the louder they get

During a break at the same show, Burkeman got talking to a retired schoolteacher named Helen. She remarked that it was hard, though, to think positive all the time, the way they advised. And at once she wagged a finger at herself: she mustn’t think like that!

Helen had fallen into the trap the psychologist Daniel Wegner studied. Whoever tries not to think about bad things unwittingly switches on an inner monitor that checks whether a bad thought has appeared. This very search keeps the thought in view. And when you are tired or under strain, the monitor takes over.

In experiments people were told about a sad event and asked not to feel sad, and their mood became worse than that of people who were asked nothing. So whoever has decided to think only about good things is doomed to keep searching for bad ones.

Burkeman compares this to a toy from the office of the psychologist Steven Hayes. A woven tube, a Chinese finger trap, grips your finger tighter the harder you pull. It lets go only if you push your finger deeper in. It is much the same with a heavy thought: you don’t chase it away or drown it out with a slogan, you let it be for a while.

Read in Livria

About the author

Oliver Burkeman is a British journalist who for many years wrote a psychology column for The Guardian. He later wrote Four Thousand Weeks, a book about living with limited time.

All books by this author: Oliver Burkeman

The Antidote: Happiness for People Who Can’t Stand Positive Thinking Quiz

Terms from the book

  • Bush
  • Watts
  • Helen
  • Hayes
  • Ellis
  • General Motors
  • survivorship bias
  • Becker
  • negative capability
  • Schuller: Robert Schuller (1926–2015), an American pastor and preacher of positive thinking, founder of the Crystal Cathedral in California, a huge church made of glass.
  • Stoics: Followers of a philosophical school of ancient Greece and Rome. They taught calm in the face of what does not depend on us. The best-known Roman Stoics are Seneca, Epictetus and Marcus Aurelius.
  • Wegner: Daniel Wegner (1948–2013), an American psychologist at Harvard. He studied why trying not to think about something makes the thought more intrusive.
  • Bronx: The Bronx is one of the five boroughs of New York City. It is home to the large New York Botanical Garden.
  • Kayes: Chris Kayes, an American professor of management at George Washington University and a former stockbroker. He studied how an obsession with a goal leads to disaster.
  • Sarasvathy: Saras Sarasvathy, a researcher of entrepreneurship. She described how experienced entrepreneurs start from the means they already have rather than from a goal set in advance.
  • Ann Arbor: A university town in the US state of Michigan.
  • McMath: Robert McMath, an American marketer. From the 1960s he collected samples of every new consumer product, and the collection became known as the museum of failure.
  • Denrell: Jerker Denrell, a Swedish management researcher who worked at Oxford. He studied the errors that arise when we look only at the successful.
  • Sandage: Scott Sandage, an American historian and author of Born Losers, a book on the history of failure in nineteenth-century America.
  • Rutgers: Rutgers University, a large public university in the US state of New Jersey.
  • Day of the Dead: A Mexican holiday at the start of November when the dead are remembered: families build home altars, decorate graves with flowers and spend the night in cemeteries.
  • San Gregorio Atlapulco: A village on the outskirts of Mexico City where the Day of the Dead is celebrated according to old customs.
  • mariachi: Mexican street bands in traditional costume, with guitars, violins and trumpets.
  • Keats: John Keats (1795–1821), an English Romantic poet. He wrote the words about negative capability in a letter to his brothers in 1817.

All terms

Similar books