Livria

Book quiz

Human Immortality: Two Supposed Objections to the Doctrine Quiz

Human Immortality: Two Supposed Objections to the Doctrine, William JamesHuman Immortality: Two Supposed Objections to the DoctrineWilliam James

If thought depends entirely on the brain, can it survive the brain’s death? The psychologist William James accepts the findings of science without reservation and shows that the conclusion “no” does not follow from them. A short lecture that decides nothing for the reader, but takes apart the two loudest objections.

Question 1 of 5

A friend says: "Thought is a function of the brain, so after death there's nothing." What would James answer?

Show the answer

Right answer: A function can also be one of letting through

James fully accepts that thought depends on the brain, but reminds us that the brain may not produce consciousness but let it through, the way an organ's keys let out the air.

Question 2 of 5

What does James compare the brain to when it lets consciousness through?

Show the answer

Right answer: A dome of colored glass

For James, steam and the light in a circuit are examples of production. He compares the brain to a thin spot in a colored dome, where light passes through and takes on color.

Question 3 of 5

A materialist demands: "Explain how the brain lets consciousness through." What does James suggest?

Show the answer

Right answer: Ask him to explain production

Science only sees that the brain and consciousness change together. Physiologists don't know how the brain produces thought either, so in this debate the two theories stand even.

Question 4 of 5

Why, according to James, do people of scientific culture give up on immortality when they think of the billions who have lived?

Show the answer

Right answer: Their imagination can't hold such numbers

The scale is so vast that our feelings refuse to take it in. We drop the premise and give up our own immortality rather than share it with such crowds.

Question 5 of 5

Your neighbor's life seems dull, as if it matters to no one. How would James see this?

Show the answer

Right answer: It's blindness in the one looking

Everyone lives from the inside with sharp intensity and joy. Whoever fails to notice this, for James and Stevenson, fails to see the whole person.

Want all of the book's key ideas? Read or listen to its retelling in Livria.