Livria

Book quiz

Talent Is Overrated Quiz

Talent Is Overrated, Geoff ColvinTalent Is OverratedGeoff Colvin

We are used to thinking that greatness is born: either you have talent or you don't. Geoff Colvin, an editor at Fortune magazine, gathers research and stories and shows the opposite. Behind outstanding skill there is almost never a gift. There is a special way of training, which he calls deliberate practice. This…

Question 1 of 5

Someone plays brilliantly, and you decide it's an inborn gift you just don't have. According to Colvin, what usually stands behind such talent?

Show the answer

Right answer: Years of early, focused practice that you don't see from outside

Behind almost every prodigy there is very early and very hard work. For Colvin, talent is not a starting condition but a result.

Question 2 of 5

An accountant has been doing the same reports for twenty years. What happens to his skill, according to Colvin?

Show the answer

Right answer: It stands still: he's working on autopilot

Once people master a task to an acceptable level, they stop thinking about it and switch to autopilot. Experience and mastery are not the same thing.

Question 3 of 5

You're learning guitar. What counts as deliberate practice, according to Colvin?

Show the answer

Right answer: Working on a weak spot with feedback, even though it's hard

Deliberate practice targets one specific weak element, gives constant feedback and happens at the edge of your ability. Repeating what you already can do is useless.

Question 4 of 5

Why does a master take in a whole situation in their field at a glance, while a beginner sees only separate details?

Show the answer

Right answer: Practice built a mental model of the field

Practice folds many small details into a few familiar patterns. A master's edge is seeing meaningful connections in their own field, not a phenomenal memory in general.

Question 5 of 5

You have no teacher to check your writing. How did Franklin solve this problem?

Show the answer

Right answer: He rebuilt essays from his notes and compared them with the original

Franklin made notes on an essay's ideas, a few days later rewrote it in his own words and compared it with the original. That way he created his own feedback.

Want all of the book's key ideas? Read or listen to its retelling in Livria.