The key ideas

The Dorito Effect: The Surprising New Truth About Food and Flavor

Mark Schatzker, 2015

Taco-flavored chips, strawberry yogurt without strawberries, chicken you cannot eat without a marinade. Journalist Mark Schatzker traces how, over half a century, food from the fields lost its flavor while laboratories learned to fake it. He shows why flavor in nature serves as a hint about what food is good for you, and what happens when that hint is separated from the food itself.

Who it is for

For people who notice that tomatoes and chicken have become bland while chips are impossible to put down, and who want to understand how the two are connected.

Junk food: food that tastes like something it is not.

A corn triangle that tastes like a taco

In the early 1960s Arch West, a vice president at Frito-Lay, talked his colleagues into making tortilla chips. The first Doritos were just salted corn triangles, and outside the American Southwest they sold poorly. So West suggested giving them a taco flavor. His colleagues laughed at him: he could not tell a thing from its flavor, they said. But chemistry could already transfer the flavor of a Mexican dish onto a fried piece of corn, and the whole country fell in love with those chips.

Journalist Mark Schatzker sees this story as a model for all modern food. Two processes ran at the same time: produce from fields and farms grew bland, while artificial flavors became ever more convincing. The author calls the meeting of the two the Dorito effect.

The book's main idea is unusual for talk about nutrition. Schatzker believes the problem is not only sugar, fat or carbohydrates. In his view, desire itself has gone wrong: we reach for food whose flavor promises one thing while its contents deliver another.

Chicken rescued by seasoning

In 1948 the American grocery chain A&P held a contest called the Chicken of Tomorrow. The winners were the chickens that put on weight fastest and looked most like a wax model. The judges did not assess flavor. Breeders took this idea to its limit: today's broiler grows to slaughter weight in about 35 days, less than half the time of the record holders of 1948, and uses a third less feed to do it.

The price was flavor. The flavor of meat depends largely on what the bird ate, and a broiler eats a bland mix of grain with added vitamins. The meat of a young bird is also more watery. Cookbooks from the turn of the twentieth century advised seasoning fried chicken with nothing but salt and pepper. Today recipes call for a marinade, garlic and paprika.

Something similar happened to vegetables. Biochemist Donald Davis compared data on 43 crops from 1950 and 1999 and found that, on average, they had come to contain fewer vitamins and minerals. Scientists call this the dilution effect: the harvest grows, but each fruit holds more water and carbohydrates and less of everything else. Schatzker counts flavor among the losses too.

Read in Livria

About the author

Mark Schatzker is a Canadian journalist who writes about food for The Globe and Mail and Bloomberg and has a regular segment on CBC radio. Before this book he wrote Steak, the story of his search for the tastiest beef.

All books by this author: Mark Schatzker

The Dorito Effect: The Surprising New Truth About Food and Flavor Quiz

Terms from the book

  • Davis
  • McCormick
  • West: Archibald (Arch) West, vice president of marketing at Frito-Lay. In the 1960s he came up with Doritos chips and suggested giving them a taco flavor.
  • Frito-Lay: An American snack maker based in Dallas. It makes Fritos, Lay's and Doritos chips.
  • tortilla: A Mexican flatbread made from corn flour. Tortilla chips are made from such flatbreads, cut into triangles and fried.
  • taco: A Mexican dish: a corn flatbread folded around a filling of meat, vegetables and sauce.
  • broiler: A meat chicken of an industrial breed developed for fast growth. Today it is slaughtered at about five weeks old.
  • A&P: A large American grocery chain of the mid-twentieth century. In 1948 it held the Chicken of Tomorrow contest.
  • breeders: People who develop new breeds of animals or varieties of plants by choosing individuals with the desired traits for reproduction.
  • dilution effect: A term used by agronomists and nutritionists: when yields grow thanks to fertilizer, irrigation and breeding, each fruit contains fewer minerals and vitamins. Schatzker extends the idea to flavor as well.
  • vanillin: The main aromatic compound of vanilla. People learned to make it from pinecones, later from clove oil and other cheap sources.
  • Haarmann: Wilhelm Haarmann, a German chemist. In 1875 he opened a vanillin factory in the town of Holzminden, which later became the center of the flavor industry.
  • Madagascar: An island state off the east coast of Africa, the main supplier of natural vanilla.
  • imitation: Here: an artificial blend of aromatic compounds that reproduces the flavor of a real product without containing it.
  • smell receptors: Sensitive cells at the top of the nasal cavity that pick up odor molecules and send a signal to the brain.
  • ecologist: A scientist who studies how living organisms relate to one another and to their environment.
  • Provenza: Frederick Provenza, an American ecologist, professor emeritus at Utah State University. He studied how goats, sheep and cattle choose their feed.
  • tannin: A bitter, astringent plant compound. There is a lot of it in red wine, in bark and in the young shoots of some shrubs.
  • phosphorus: A mineral the body uses to build bones and teeth. Metabolism cannot do without it.
  • Grapeade: A sweet grape-flavored drink from the American brand AriZona. Its main ingredients are water and corn syrup.
  • corn syrup: A cheap sweet syrup made from corn starch. In Grapeade it is high-fructose corn syrup, widely used in the United States instead of sugar.
  • fiber: Plant fibers that the body barely digests. The gut needs them to work.
  • Sucram: A sweet flavoring for livestock feed. Its smell reminds animals of their mother's milk, so they eat the feed more willingly.
  • University of Oregon: A public university in the American state of Oregon. In 2008 its neuroimaging center scanned the brains of participants in the milkshake experiment.
  • food addiction: A researchers' concept, not an accepted diagnosis: eating behavior that resembles addiction to a substance. It was measured with the Yale Food Addiction Scale.
  • barred rock: An old American chicken breed (barred Plymouth Rock) with striped black-and-white feathers. These chickens grow more slowly than a broiler and need space to roam outdoors.
  • Memphis: A city in the American state of Tennessee, known for its fried chicken and barbecue restaurants.
  • deep satiety: Provenza's hypothesis, not an established scientific fact: food that meets many of the body's needs at once satisfies sooner and with a smaller portion.
  • Klee: Harry Klee, an American molecular biologist at the University of Florida. He has spent many years studying what determines the flavor of tomatoes.
  • Garden Gem: A tomato variety bred by Harry Klee by crossing the tasty old variety Maglia Rosa with a high-yield industrial one.
  • Label Rouge: A French state quality label. A chicken with this label is raised partly outdoors and lives at least 81 days.

All terms

Similar books